Florida's Workers' Compensation System Unconstitutional, So Says 11th Circuit Court Judge Jorge Cueto
In 1935, Florida first enacted a workers' compensation system for the state's employers and employees. The idea was to provide a greater degree of fairness and certainty for each. The primary advantage for employers was the immunity from most personal injury lawsuits, making it easier to anticipate expenses, while employees would receive benefits without first having to prove negligence against the employer. It was a model patterned on similar systems adopted in other states. Both sides gained, both sides lost, but the overall outcome was positive.
That is, until greed began to creep into the system. It didn't take long.
Through legislative might, business interests soon began to whittle away at workers' rights and benefits. From time to time, the courts slowed and reversed the erosion, but workers could do little in the long run to resist the rising tide of selfishness and greed.
Not surprisingly, the high mark of this tide of selfishness and greed came during Jeb Bush's reign as Florida's governor. Taking a page from his big brother George's system in Texas, Jeb spearheaded efforts to gut Florida's workers' compensation system. 2002's legislative session broke the system. Benefits were slashed and injured workers were denied the right to effective legal counsel.
Jeb received champagne toasts in boardrooms from Key West to northwest Florida. Mission Accomplished!